✕

Forgot password?

Register Now
A Review of the Innovative Development of CNPC Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd.

2017-06-19

Author:自保网/chinacaptive.cn/captive.org

Scan with WeChat to share
QR Code
Close

        Hope and challenges have been intertwined throughout the development of CNPC Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "CNPC Captive"). Today, captive operating capability has become a hallmark of the core strength of international energy companies. As the first captive insurer in mainland China and still a novel concept, how CNPC Captive can effectively realize its unique value amid an immature policy environment and limited public awareness is a question its team has pondered deeply.

  The challenges of exploration are answered by innovation. In the three years since its establishment at the end of 2013, CNPC Captive has served the Group's development strategy and innovated in philosophy, model and business development, achieving benefits while controlling risk; building on profitability earned in its very first year of operation, it has worked hard to maintain an upward business trajectory, with cumulative total profits of RMB 900 million. Over these three years, CNPC Captive has proceeded in a down-to-earth manner, striving to forge an innovative development path for a captive insurer that meets the Group's strategic needs and carries the distinctive character of PetroChina, delivering a satisfactory report card through concrete action.

1.jpg

  Chart comparing the claims settlement cycles of CNPC Captive and commercial insurance in 2016

  Philosophy innovation: a unique tool for cost reduction and efficiency enhancement, and a key lever for optimizing the value chain

  Philosophy innovation underpins a high starting point. The birth of CNPC Captive not only carries the mission of pilot exploration for innovation in China's insurance industry, but is also an important measure in the Group's deepening reform. For the insurance industry, CNPC Captive is an innovator in industry development; for the Group, it is a "special forces" unit that supports the implementation of the Group's strategy, helps win the tough battle of "expanding revenue and reducing expenditure, cutting costs and boosting efficiency", and enhances core competitiveness.

  First, the essence of insurance is to pool risk-related property losses by transferring risk to the insurer, which agrees to provide the insured with financial assistance and risk-handling services when the relevant losses occur. For conglomerate enterprises, given their enormous scale of operations, the number of units exposed to risk losses far exceeds that of ordinary social groups; this makes it more economical for them to adopt moderate risk retention in their loss-response strategies. Captive insurance is widely applied in corporate risk management programs precisely because, through a special form of risk retention, it can retain part or all of specific loss exposures, meeting the dual needs of risk control and cost savings and achieving the optimal outcome of "cost reduction and efficiency enhancement".

  Second, thanks to the existence of CNPC Captive as a professional captive insurer, premium expenditures that would otherwise have been net cash outflows remain within the system and are transformed into part of the Group's consolidated profits. Of the premium structure, the management fees and underwriting profits that commercial insurers would otherwise have taken are retained by CNPC Captive, leveraging the preferential advantages of its own financial license, and flow into a capital reservoir—not only providing a buffer against future catastrophe risk, but also creating new profit sources for the Group through the optimization and reshaping of the value chain.

  Third, CNPC Captive's strategic positioning as a "professional risk management platform and insurance arrangement tool" gives it both an innate advantage in understanding the Group's risk profile and an intrinsic motivation to support the Group in achieving intrinsic safety. Through a continuous work cycle of risk identification, analysis and response, CNPC Captive keeps exploring the role of insurance tools in supporting risk control; it innovates insurance products for the special needs of the Group's different risk types, expands the scope of coverage, and achieves sound risk transfer through direct access to the reinsurance market. While effectively supporting the improvement of the Group's risk protection system, it also further promotes the reduction of systemic risk across society, playing a positive insurance role in the stable and orderly functioning of the macroeconomy.

1.jpg

  Schematic diagram of CNPC Captive's core business

  Model innovation: clenching fingers into a fist to harness economies of scale, with lean outsourcing to reduce management and control costs

  Model innovation drives rapid development. As the first captive insurer in mainland China and an innovator in the insurance industry, CNPC Captive has begun to demonstrate the innovative effects of its new model since its establishment.

  CNPC Captive focuses on building platform and tool functions, leveraging its professional risk management advantages and its role as a link coordinating internal insurance resources to support improvements in the concentration, standardization and professionalism of the Group's overall business. Through CNPC Captive's work, the Group can not only cope with and smooth out cyclical rate fluctuations in the commercial insurance market, but also achieve direct access to the reinsurance market, bypassing traditional commercial insurance institutions. The centralized and unified scale effect, coupled with a direct channel to the reinsurance market, not only makes the Group's overall risk transfer costs lower, but also—by directly capturing the reinsurance market's feedback benefits relative to the primary market—brings the cost of risk transfer closer to the pure cost of loss risk.

  In its domestic insurance business, CNPC Captive promotes classified and bundled insurance programs, with a focus on further integrating regional lines of business, effectively reducing the unit cost of risk protection through scaled operations. In its overseas insurance business, it implements a model of ceding insurance interests back in proportion to equity shares, successfully assembled a regional "master policy" for the Kazakhstan region, promoted further integration of overseas insurance business, and explored innovative operating models such as global fronting and the establishment of an international network of surveying partners for overseas claims—comprehensively supporting the further protection of the Group's overseas interests.

  As a professional captive insurer, CNPC Captive is dedicated exclusively to serving the Group and its member companies. Serving the Group's overall interests, CNPC Captive focuses on innovating lean and efficient operating models such as business outsourcing, engages in extensive peer cooperation, and has rapidly raised the professional service standards of its business through deep integration with and rapid absorption into the insurance market. Through various business acceptance methods including direct insurance, co-insurance and reinsurance, it has built a global business cooperation network commensurate with its operating scale and established relatively stable partnerships with industry peers; it continuously optimizes reinsurance treaty arrangements and enhances its rapid-response claims service capability, demonstrating its unique value. On this basis, CNPC Captive firmly upholds a development philosophy of "international vision, strategic awareness, courage to break through, and leadership in innovation". To fully support the integration of the Group's overseas insurance business and make full use of preferential policies for offshore captive insurers, it has initiated preparations for overseas branches and has made important progress, entering the final approval stage.

1.jpg  

       Schematic diagram of CNPC Captive's entrusted management of the Security Fund

  Business innovation: identifying pain points in risk management and raising control standards through customization

  Business innovation sharpens the tools of development. The petroleum and petrochemical industry is technology- and capital-intensive with a high degree of risk. How to "tailor-make" a risk protection system that closely centers on PetroChina as the parent—combining the industry's risk characteristics with insurance market requirements—to help the Group enhance intrinsic safety is an eternal subject of CNPC Captive's continuous exploration.

  Since commencing formal operations in 2014, CNPC Captive has pooled its efforts and pioneered innovation, achieving remarkable results in four business areas: underwriting, claims, entrusted management of the Security Fund, and risk research.

  In underwriting, new lines of business are tailor-made for the industry's special risks. To meet the Group's own risk protection needs, CNPC Captive has focused on the targeted development of new products. After taking over the entrusted management of the Security Fund, while ensuring the fund's smooth and orderly operation and further improving the quality and efficiency of its claims, it promoted the integration of the Security Fund's loss compensation function with captive business and products, and worked to strengthen catastrophe hedging functions. Aiming at the risk characteristics and insurance needs of refining and chemical enterprises, it successfully assembled a controlled master policy for refining and chemical enterprise property insurance, which officially incepted on January 1, 2017; all of the Group's refining and chemical enterprises were brought within the scope of coverage, with a policy sum insured of RMB 362.9 billion and premiums of RMB 109 million. After the Tianjin Port "8·12" explosion accident, in view of the high-risk nature of firefighters' work, the high standards of treatment and compensation, and their special and critical role in disaster relief and loss mitigation, CNPC Captive immediately set about developing supplementary insurance for firefighters engaged in emergency rescue and disaster relief, tailoring insurance solutions to support the further scientific improvement of the Group's post-disaster loss mitigation protection system.

  In claims service, CNPC Captive adheres to the captive service philosophy of "proactive, efficient and professional", takes supporting the Group's risk control as its starting point, strengthens rapid response, grasps the essence of claims risk control, streamlines the claims handling process, carefully designs claims solutions, and supports clients in disaster and loss reduction; it carries out targeted client-facing business training and continuously shortens the claims cycle, promoting an all-round improvement in claims service efficiency and quality. It has made great efforts to increase advance payments on cases where it is lead insurer, striving to make advance payments on all eligible cases and fully supporting clients' emergency rescue and disaster relief.

  Under the Group's unified deployment and organization, CNPC Captive piloted insurable risk assessments for three businesses—exploration and development, pipelines, and city gas—gaining a preliminary systematic understanding of insurable risks in the Group's main business areas. Through standardized work processes, it scientifically revealed the categories of insurable risks facing the Group and the potential severity of risk losses, deepening systematic understanding of various insurable risks. This is not only a measure that drives the Group to improve risk control, but also an effective channel through which the insurance market can directly understand the Group's safety and risk management standards and characteristics, an important basis for bringing reinsurance market pricing toward reasonableness, and of great significance for giving play to insurance's risk transfer function.

  As a strategic professional risk management tool, CNPC Captive presents a qualitative difference from commercial insurers by virtue of its unique value. At present, as the Group is in a critical period of building a world-class integrated international energy company and implementing the "13th Five-Year Plan", the national "Belt and Road" strategy, the rapid development of the domestic insurance market, and the full implementation of the Group's resources, markets, internationalization and innovation strategies undoubtedly provide enormous room for the Group to give full play to the unique role of captive insurance.

1.jpg

  Schematic diagram of CNPC Captive's overseas business
  [Main Business Cases]

  Underwriting: professional and efficient

  Since its establishment, CNPC Captive has significantly increased the breadth and depth of its participation in head-office controlled master programs, regional approvals, filed products and overseas projects, covering all lines of business involved in both the construction and operational periods, and has acquired the capability to underwrite the full range of energy insurance lines. Its domestic insurance business fully participates in underwriting all of the Group's lines except motor insurance, and it has taken on, as lead insurer, five major oil and gas risk master programs—drilling equipment insurance, well control cost insurance, long-distance pipeline enterprise property insurance, LNG enterprise property insurance, and reserve oil depot property insurance—with cumulative insured assets of RMB 551.5 billion; by the end of 2016, its overseas business coverage had expanded to 25 overseas projects in 15 countries.

  In 2015, it underwrote construction insurance, liability insurance and cargo transportation insurance for the China-Russia cooperative Yamal LNG project operating inside the Arctic Circle, with a project sum insured of USD 24 billion and premium income of nearly RMB 70 million, with cessions benefiting the domestic insurance market; since September 2015, with the full support of the Exploration and Development Branch and the Iraq project company, CNPC Captive has underwritten the Rumaila oilfield project in Iraq for two consecutive years, with annual premiums of RMB 20 million. As part of the Group's package cooperation with BP, the successful cooperation between overseas enterprises and CNPC Captive has become a typical example of safeguarding the Group's overall insurance interests and has boosted the development of the Group's overseas insurance business. At the end of 2016, CNPC Captive successfully entered the Mozambique Area 4 project, underwriting well control insurance. This project is the world's second to integrate offshore floating LNG extraction and processing; once in production, Mozambique will become the world's largest LNG exporter.

  Claims: fast settlement and advance payments

  Among CNPC Captive's five lead-underwritten lines, long-distance pipeline property insurance is characterized by numerous claims, large reported losses and difficulty in collecting documentation. Effectively implementing the "advance payment" policy and controlling the settlement cycle are the usual difficulties and priorities in claims handling. To address this, CNPC Captive collects claims materials through historical data analysis and on-site surveys, analyzing and resolving problems at the source. In 2016, it achieved a settlement cycle of 112 days and a settlement rate of 73% for pipeline cases—markedly better than the 2014 claims service level of the Group's commercial insurance, which had a settlement cycle of 524 days and a settlement rate of 4.87%. Starting from the need to guarantee the intrinsic safety of regional companies, CNPC Captive provides distinctive claims services that are professional, reasonable, proactive and efficient.

  At 13:53 on December 20, 2015, CNPC Captive received a report that a sudden landslide at the Hengtaiyu Industrial Park in Shenzhen, served by the eastern pipeline, had damaged pipeline facilities supplying gas to Hong Kong. CNPC Captive immediately made emergency arrangements and activated its special urgent claims response procedure. On the 21st, it dispatched a loss adjuster to the site to survey the losses; on the 22nd, CNPC Captive's advance payment of RMB 10 million was in place, strongly supporting the enterprise's post-disaster reconstruction. When the case was settled in February 2017, CNPC Captive had paid total claims of RMB 17.17 million, and the case was named one of the "Top Ten Influential Claims Cases of 2016 in China's Insurance (Property) Industry".

  On June 28, 2015, CNPC Captive received a claim report that Bohai Drilling's directional well technical service company had suffered a stuck-pipe accident while operating in Iran. After Bohai Drilling's repeated attempts at releasing the stuck pipe and fishing operations proved ineffective, and the downhole wireless measurement-while-drilling instruments were confirmed lost, CNPC Captive, comprehensively considering the nature of the damage and the location of the loss, activated the special-case claims procedure. Using supporting materials such as on-site photos, the insured list and equipment purchase contracts, it completed the claims liability and loss determination procedures, ultimately paying claims of RMB 849,900 and successfully closing the case.

  CNPC Captive has improved and upgraded its service philosophy and innovatively applied claims tools, striving to solve the pain point of obtaining meteorological certificates for insurance claims. In May 2016, CNPC Captive signed a service agreement with the China Meteorological Administration under which official meteorological certificates can be issued through its meteorological system; claims business of all enterprises across the Group can benefit from this service. To date, CNPC Captive has issued more than 600 meteorological certificates for pipeline and sales enterprises, facilitating meteorological evidence collection for claims cases and effectively accelerating the claims process.

  Security Fund: catastrophe hedging

  Since its establishment, CNPC Captive has managed the Security Fund on an entrusted basis for three complete operating years, accepting 291 Security Fund claims reports and paying losses totaling RMB 227 million. The average settlement cycle was shortened year by year from 90 days in 2014 to 84 days in 2016.

  On July 18, 2014, Typhoon Rammasun, the ninth typhoon of the year, made landfall in southern China, affecting 146 gas stations; Guangxi Petrochemical suffered severe losses, with reported losses of RMB 120 million. Upon receiving the report, CNPC Captive immediately activated its claims emergency mechanism and conducted an on-site survey at the earliest opportunity. On the basis of a first advance claims payment of RMB 2.7 million made on the 21st, it successively paid total advance claims of RMB 32.7 million to support the enterprise's resumption of production. At the same time, the Security Fund activated its hedging fund reservoir, paying RMB 86.76 million to the enterprise, and drew on catastrophe risk transfer insurance, obtaining claims of RMB 47.48 million from commercial insurers to compensate for the Security Fund's own losses. While giving play to the Security Fund's catastrophe hedging function, risk transfer through insurance effectively reduced the Group's property losses.

  On July 26, 2015, a fire broke out in the atmospheric and vacuum distillation unit at Qingyang Petrochemical. CNPC Captive responded rapidly, rushing to the accident site the next day and paying an advance claim of RMB 7 million after the survey. CNPC Captive also actively supported the enterprise in collecting claims materials, pushing the case to settlement within 98 days, with total claims paid of RMB 12.78 million.

        [Expert View]

        Captive Insurers: A Strategic Consideration in Multinational Enterprises' Risk Management

  Over recent decades, the role of captive insurers has continuously evolved—from initial technical functions, such as accumulating hedging funds and shielding the parent company's profits from the impact of underwriting cycles, to gradually developing higher-level strategic functions that support the parent company's development needs. To bring out the strategic role of a captive insurer, one must first understand its unique value in the following aspects:

  1. Helping the parent company build a closed-loop control system for insurable risks

  A captive insurer is an important tool for the parent company to "scientifically control risk losses and ensure stable economic operation". The captive's work continuously accumulates the parent's risk data and historical accident data; through systematic training, on-site surveys and assessments, it builds a systematic understanding of all insurable risk types facing the parent and the potential severity of losses, and then offers improvement suggestions. Starting from the entire process of pre-loss prevention and avoidance and post-loss mitigation, it implements and monitors the risk management plan to enhance the parent's intrinsic safety.

  2. Achieving direct access to the reinsurance market

  Through direct access to the reinsurance market, a captive insurer can not only transfer risk and conduct professional risk financing, but also delivers three further benefits:

  First, it can reduce (retain) intermediary costs. A commercial insurer's premium income covers not only pure risk costs but also commercial market profits. Through direct access to the reinsurance market, the captive keeps premiums within the parent company's system while achieving risk transfer, improving capital utilization efficiency, converting former cost expenditures into profit, and reducing the parent's cost outflows.

  Second, it can enhance bargaining power in the reinsurance market. Compared with commercial insurers, a captive understands the parent's risk management and control capabilities better and can better demonstrate to the reinsurance market the parent's own risk characteristics as well as its risk control system and its effectiveness, thereby obtaining more realistic pricing from the reinsurance market and reducing the parent's risk management costs.

  Third, it can accumulate pricing strength to support the parent in effective financial planning. Reinsurance market quotations are closer to pure risk prices, which helps the captive grasp the market source prices of the parent's various pure risks, providing pricing and planning support for the parent's coordinated implementation of risk control strategies.

  3. Helping the parent unify and standardize risk management

  For oil companies operating globally, the laws of the host countries of overseas investment projects differ, and project risk control characteristics and capabilities also vary. The parent can use the captive as the executor to achieve unified risk management and insurance arrangements. For special regions and special risks that the commercial insurance market has difficulty covering, the captive can tailor-make special insurance products, holistically enhancing the professionalism and controllability of the parent's risk management and improving the parent's risk protection system.

  Establishing a captive insurer is a strategic decision in the parent's own risk management. Given the special nature of the captive's business sources, the parent's support plays a decisive role in realizing the captive's value, mainly in three respects:

  First, for the parent, a captive is not simply a substitute for commercial insurers, but an important strategic tool and platform that helps the parent improve its risk and financial management.

  Second, judging from the development models of mature international captives, since a captive's business comes entirely from its parent, unified policies from the parent and their consistent execution are the primary condition for the captive to play its role through business development.

  Third, judging from the development of the international captive industry, due to the lack of historical underwriting data and claims data, it is common for captives to be unprofitable in their first 3–5 years, or to suffer losses from major claims. But with the parent's continued support, coupled with their own accumulation of experience and business optimization, captives' profitability gradually strengthens. Therefore, in the early years of a captive, most companies do not use profit as an assessment indicator, but instead devote themselves to enabling it to perform its special function of optimizing the risk management and financial management systems.

Source: CNPC News Center 2017-06-19