On July 7, 2017, the Captive Insurance Committee of the Insurance Institute of China organized its first captive development seminar. Leaders and experts from the Development and Reform Department of the CIRC, the Insurance Institute of China, CNPC Captive, China Railway Captive, COSCO Captive, Sinopec Captive, CNOOC Captive, Guangdong Yuedian Captive (in preparation), China Datang Captive (in preparation), China Taiping Insurance (Hong Kong), China Reinsurance Group, Swiss Re, Munich Re, Ernst & Young, PricewaterhouseCoopers and Sinosoft Co., Ltd. attended the meeting. The meeting was hosted by CNPC Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd.

Feng Zhanjun, Deputy Secretary-General of the Insurance Institute of China, chaired the meeting and said that since its establishment, the Captive Insurance Committee of the Insurance Institute of China has been committed to building a platform for communication and exchange among the captive industry in China and abroad. Focusing on learning from international captive development experience, strengthening the exploration of frontier theory and practice in China's captive market, and promoting exchanges and cooperation among Chinese captive insurers, it has done substantial promotional work and achieved fruitful results. In the next stage, it will actively organize special research on captive development and regulation in China, professional training seminars for captive insurers, the editing of professional captive research publications, and exchanges with the captive industry at home and abroad, discussing the hot and difficult issues currently facing China's captive market and offering suggestions to promote the development of China's captive market.
The meeting discussion concluded that captive insurers focus on enterprise risk management and are the vehicle through which large enterprises underwrite the risks of their own core businesses. Internationally, they are major providers of liability insurance, innovators in the insurance industry, and important supplements to traditional commercial insurers, playing an irreplaceable role in the field of alternative risk transfer. Vigorously developing captives in China is conducive to improving China's insurance market system and accords with the central authorities' new financial development philosophy of finance supporting the development of the real economy.
The meeting held that the global captive market landscape has begun to change in recent years: the European and American captive markets are maturing, while captive insurers in emerging markets, including China, are beginning to rise. China's captive market has grown from scratch—domestic enterprises have now established 9 captive insurers, developing relatively fast in the Asia-Pacific region. Further improving China's captive regulatory system is of positive significance for the healthy development of China's captive market.
Delegates proposed that Chinese captive insurers should develop into the risk management centers of enterprises, and suggested improving China's captive regulatory system in light of this characteristic. They discussed current captive hot topics—including establishing a C-ROSS regulatory system suited to the characteristics of captive insurers, reinsurance regulation of captive insurers, single-risk limits for captive insurers, and regulation of related-party transactions and capital flows between captive insurers and their parent companies—and put forward the following specific suggestions:
1. It is suggested that the business boundaries of captive insurers be defined by risk attributes, and that a regulatory system commensurate with captive insurers' responsibilities be established. Judging from international development experience, captive insurers are usually regarded by their parent companies as risk management entities—cost centers for the parent's risk management rather than profit centers for insurance business. Captive insurers do not take third-party business as their main development direction, but they also need to achieve risk diversification through related-enterprise business, upstream and downstream industrial chain business, and reinsurance inward business. Therefore, by their nature, captive insurers show development characteristics clearly different from traditional commercial insurers, and international captive insurers usually define their business boundaries by the risk attributes involved with their parent companies.
2. It is suggested to study a C-ROSS regulatory regime suited to the characteristics of captive insurers. Captive insurers are mainly established with investment from their parent companies, with limited premium growth, highly streamlined departmental structures, and characteristics such as separation between place of registration and actual place of operation. They differ from ordinary commercial insurers in solvency regulation, department and position settings, related-party transactions, information disclosure, outsourcing management and regulatory reporting.
3. It is suggested to relax restrictions on the proportion of captive insurers' capital utilization and allow funds to flow back to parent companies. Under the current insurance capital utilization regulatory regime, captive insurers may only entrust insurance capital investment managers who meet CIRC standards, and there are proportion limits on investments in related parties. These provisions do not suit the characteristics of captive insurers and increase their capital management costs.
4. It is suggested to lift restrictions on the proportion of reinsurance inward business. First, under China's current regulatory provisions, issuing companies must retain 20% of premiums plus certain fees, creating obstacles to cooperation between captive insurers and domestic commercial insurers. Second, some captive insurers' cooperation projects with other parties also have reinsurance inward needs. Third, international experience shows that allowing captive insurers to accept reinsurance inward of same-industry risks helps improve their risk diversification capabilities.
5. It is suggested to study regulatory policies for insurance business interaction between captive insurers in mainland China and Hong Kong. Of the captive insurers already operating in China, 3 are established in the mainland and 3 in Hong Kong. With the advancement of China's "Belt and Road" initiative, many large state-owned enterprises have both domestic assets and substantial overseas assets. Based on the current business realities of captive insurers, there are both cases where captives established in Hong Kong cede domestic business to Hong Kong, and cases where Hong Kong captives underwrite overseas business and cede it back to domestic insurers. Under the current regulatory regime, Hong Kong is treated as an overseas jurisdiction, and the related reinsurance arrangements increase captive insurers' costs and solvency requirements. Given Hong Kong's special status in China, it is suggested to study special regulatory policies for Hong Kong reinsurance business and to study national treatment policies in China for captive insurers established in Hong Kong.
6. It is suggested to study regulatory policies for the group-based development of captive insurers. Most of the large enterprises that have established captive insurers in China also hold insurance brokerage licenses, and have proposed developing captive life insurance business. Current regulations require that senior executives of different insurance institutions may not concurrently hold posts. The group-based development of captive insurers has positive significance for streamlining the management costs of the parent's insurance segment and reducing senior management positions.
7. It is suggested to raise the 10% single-risk limit requirement for captive insurers. This requirement restricts captive insurers' underwriting capacity; foreign captive insurers are not subject to such proportion limits.
The meeting hopes that the Captive Committee will establish special research topics, draw on mature international captive experience, and conduct in-depth research on the development path of captive insurers with Chinese characteristics.
