✕

Forgot password?

Register Now
The Strategic Significance of COSCO Shipping Group's Establishment of a Captive Insurer

2017-10-03

Author:自保网/chinacaptive.cn/captive.org

Scan with WeChat to share
QR Code
Close

        On December 18, 2016, COSCO Shipping Group announced the establishment of a captive insurer preparatory team; after more than two months of preparation, it formally announced the establishment of COSCO Shipping Property Insurance Captive Co., Ltd. (hereinafter "COSCO Shipping Captive") on February 17, 2017. This is the seventh captive insurer in China and the first in the domestic shipping sector.

         A captive insurer is an insurance or reinsurance company owned by a large non-insurance enterprise that underwrites or reinsures the risks of its parent company or affiliated companies. According to historical records, the first commercial insurance company (the Phoenix Insurance Company) was founded in the 18th century; after Frederic Reiss proposed the captive concept in the 1950s, many large enterprises established captives in the 1970s and early 1980s, and captive insurers entered a period of rapid development. The world-shocking "9/11" attacks further drove up rates in the international insurance market, attracting capital market funds into the insurance market, with captive insurers increasing at a rate of more than 500 per year. By the end of 2005, there were already numerous captive insurers worldwide, with total investment exceeding USD 100 million and total premium income of USD 26 billion. According to incomplete statistics, 80% of Fortune 500 companies have established captive insurers.

        Among global shipping enterprises, the first to establish a captive insurer was Japan's Mitsui O.S.K. Lines (1991); followed by Nippon Yusen Kaisha (1998); the Maersk Group established a captive insurer in 2012, with registered capital in the tens of thousands of US dollars.

        COSCO Shipping Captive is an insurance company approved by the China Insurance Regulatory Commission (hereinafter "CIRC"), funded solely by its parent company COSCO Shipping Group or jointly with its controlled subsidiaries, and providing property insurance, short-term health insurance and short-term accident insurance only to the parent company and its controlled subsidiaries. The captive's registered capital is RMB 2 billion.

        At present, the domestic captive industry in China is still in its infancy. After the CIRC issued the "Notice on Issues Concerning the Regulation of Captive Insurance Companies" in December 2013, three large state-owned petroleum and chemical enterprises—CNPC, Sinopec and CNOOC—successively established captive insurers from 2014 onward.
        For large shipping enterprises, amid an 8-year downturn in the shipping industry, establishing a professional captive insurer usually plays a very important role in corporate risk management. A number of world-renowned shipping enterprises have established captive insurers.

        1 The Strategic Significance of Establishing a Captive Insurer

        1.1 Cost Savings

        Commercial insurers charge relatively high insurance fees; in addition to pure premiums, their premium income includes loading charges. Apart from cession costs, the great majority of such loading charges cover operating, management and marketing expenses—costs that can be saved by establishing a captive insurer. In addition, when shipping enterprises buy hull insurance or other property insurance on the commercial insurance market and then purchase cargo damage and shortage insurance for their clients (cargo owners), they often have to bear unreasonable premium rates.

        With a professional captive insurer, the insureds are the parent company and its related enterprises (including cargo owners served long-term by freight forwarding companies), and the captive has a better understanding of the insureds' risk conditions, operating conditions, safety management standards and surrounding environment. Therefore, the information asymmetry problem between ordinary commercial insurers and shipping enterprises and their clients (cargo owners) does not exist, allowing a captive to tailor the most reasonable premium rate for the shipping enterprise and reduce insurance costs. Such tailor-made captive rates also save a considerable sum of commissions previously paid to insurance brokers or agents.

        According to Maersk Group statistics, insuring through its captive can save one-third of insurance costs, enabling the Maersk Group to attract cargo owners with preferential low freight rates. This both increases cargo sources and raises vessel load factors, while reducing insurance cost expenditures—allowing the Maersk Group to remain profitable even in difficult years for shipping.

        1.2 Expanding the Scope of Insurance and Avoiding Shipping Risks

        A captive insurer can tailor insurance solutions for its parent company and subsidiaries, reasonably sharing operating and management risks.

        Some commercial insurers only cover total loss for shipping enterprises' vessels and do not underwrite ordinary hull insurance; others, acting in their own interest, demand deductibles as high as 20%–30% of the sum insured on hull insurance, or list exclusions in policies to reduce their claims liability after a casualty.

        Another example: commercial insurers are only willing to bear 3/4 of collision liability for ship collision accidents; they are unwilling to cover work injury, dispatch and repatriation costs for the shipping enterprise's crew members, or loss of private belongings and property; and unwilling to bear 26 types of costs arising from shipowners' liability, including oil pollution damage caused by ship collisions, personal injury compensation, wreck and cargo salvage, oil pollution cleanup, cargo damage and shortage and related extra costs, and container damage and loss.

        For all the above shipping risks that commercial insurers cannot cover, a captive insurer can provide coordinated and reasonable solutions at its discretion, so as to spread the operating and management risks of the parent company and its subsidiaries (such as COSCO Shipping Heavy Industry, COSCO Shipping Ports and COSCO Shipping Logistics).

        1.3 Reducing the Tax Burden

        In the past, to address compensation for vessel risks that commercial insurers were unwilling to bear (such as 1/4 collision liability compensation, losses from collisions, groundings and strandings in non-total-loss situations, compensation within deductibles, and exclusion risks), some large shipping enterprises usually set up their own compensation funds. However, under the Accounting Law of the People's Republic of China, such compensation funds cannot be included in enterprise costs, greatly increasing the tax burden.

        A professional captive insurer can treat this expenditure as a special form of corporate risk retention, providing a better solution to this problem—not only allowing paid claims and expenses to be counted as costs, but also obtaining tax relief benefits on reported claims.

        Bermuda, the world's largest captive domicile, has a relatively mature financial regulatory system and preferential policies; establishing a professional captive insurer generally takes only a few weeks. Captives can also enjoy preferential tax treatment on underwriting reserves at offshore registration locations (such as Bermuda). Compared with commercial insurers, the threshold for registering a captive in Bermuda is lower—the minimum capital requirement is generally only a few hundred thousand US dollars, far below the tens of millions or even hundreds of millions of dollars required of commercial insurers.

        COSCO Shipping Captive is registered in the Pudong Free Trade Zone and will enjoy certain policy and tax preferences, directly reducing the enterprise's tax burden.

        1.4 Broader Coverage and Better Service

        Commercial insurers only provide coverage for shipping risks they deem insurable, and either shy away from special risks or deliberately raise deductibles to levels shipowners cannot bear—often departing from the shipowners' original insurance intent. A professional captive insurer's underwriting scope breaks through the commercial insurers' limits on insurable risks; taking the resolution of parent and subsidiary risks as its own mission, it launches the most suitable personalized products (often for high-risk projects commercial insurers are unwilling to cover, with higher sums insured and longer terms) or combines different types of risks. This gives the parent company and its subsidiaries more flexible risk control.

        A captive insurer can control the parent company's existing risks through policy terms and conditions, and can also tailor insurance products and revise insurance clauses for the parent, giving the parent better insurance services.

        1.5 Raising the Level of Insurance Protection

        When an accident occurs, the captive can give full play to the parent's top shipping and seafaring talent, analyze the causes of accidents, summarize lessons learned, reasonably assess claim amounts and clarify the sharing of liability for insured events—obtaining high-quality professional loss adjustment reports without going through a loss adjusting company, and saving the related expense. The parent can compile these accident lessons into volumes as training materials for frontline shipping and seafaring personnel, benefiting the parent's talent development and the improvement of personnel quality.

        The establishment of a captive insurer not only helps the parent obtain compensation at the fastest speed with its rights protected to the greatest extent, but also promotes the all-round development of risk management, thereby enhancing the parent's standing.

Capture.PNG

        2 Challenges and Opportunities Facing Captive Insurers

        The greatest advantage of commercial insurers is that, according to the law of large numbers, they spread the risk compensation of a given insured across all policyholders (that is, all insureds under the commercial insurer). Commercial insurers are backed by relatively complete reinsurance systems; when huge claims occur, the claims funding pressure is shared by their reinsurers. Therefore, when establishing a captive insurer, attention should be paid to the following challenges:

        (1) The parent company and its subsidiaries should strengthen employees' professional quality and safety awareness training, implement safety and quality management across all staff, all processes and all aspects, and raise the risk control standards of operating companies and ship management companies.

        (2) Lay out reinsurance well, spreading risk globally, and hire the world's best company managers such as MARSH (Marsh) to manage the captive's business, improving personnel quality so that the captive's soft power aligns with international standards relatively quickly.

        (3) During the captive's start-up period, the parent should provide the captive with relatively sufficient capital after careful calculation.

        On the basis of fully analyzing risk tolerance, the captive should determine its risk retention fund and take reinsurance arrangements seriously as the top priority. Correctly determining the captive's risk retention fund reduces the captive's overall capital risk.

        The so-called captive risk tolerance refers to the maximum unbudgeted financial loss the parent company can bear in any fiscal year. Taking COSCO Shipping Group's 2016 annual financial report as sample data, the specific steps for analyzing COSCO Shipping Captive's risk tolerance are as follows:

        (1) Normally, an enterprise's risk retention fund should not exceed 1.25 times after-tax profit. Based on the financial report, it is recommended that the cap on the risk retention fund be set at RMB ____ ten thousand.

        (2) Using five key financial figures—working capital, net assets, total assets, total revenue and expected earnings—calculated by the weighted average method, it is recommended that the cap on the risk retention fund be set at RMB 2.9 billion.

        (3) Through sensitivity analysis under seven loss scenarios, to avoid significant impact of the risk retention fund on return on equity and return on assets, it is recommended that the cap on the risk retention fund be set at RMB ____ ten thousand.

        Based on the above analysis, COSCO Shipping Captive should keep its annual risk retention fund cap at RMB ____ ten thousand. This risk fund can address the common types of risks facing the parent company; the remaining risks can be ceded through reinsurance to world-renowned banks and insurance groups.

        In addition, COSCO Shipping Captive should also consider the following factors.

        (1) Whether the shipping enterprise's risk appetite covers only accidents such as vessel and pollution incidents; and whether retaining more risk—and the corresponding increase or decrease in risk volatility—accords with COSCO Shipping Group's risk appetite.

        (2) Whether there are any restrictions on retaining more risk, or whether it complies with the relevant regulatory requirements of the CIRC.

        (3) When the risk retention fund is exhausted, whether to make up the shortfall from the parent's revenue or profit, or to adopt some form of financing; and how losses are allocated within the group.

        3 Differences Between Shipping Enterprises' Captive Insurers, P&I Clubs, and Commercial Insurers

        (1) A shipowners' mutual insurance association is an organization in which numerous shipowners participate, entrusting the association with managing the investment and operation of insurance funds, case handling and claims. A single shipowner (insured) cannot independently control the mutual association and only has voting rights on specific matters.

        (2) Members of a mutual association pay only membership fees, not insurance premiums. The association's managers determine, for each fiscal year, the amount of advance premiums and whether supplementary premiums are required. Advance premiums are paid in a lump sum at the start of the insurance year; for new members, they are negotiated based on vessel gross tonnage, age, type, technical condition, operating characteristics, class of risk and historical claims record, with an insurance period of one year. Supplementary premiums are paid in one or several installments as decided by the board after the insurance year's accounts are finalized.

        (3) A captive insurer's investors are its parent company and sibling companies. The parent has absolute control over the captive; but in essence, a captive is established following the model, procedures and process requirements of a commercial insurer, and is by nature a specific kind of commercial insurance company.

        (4) The difference between a captive insurer and a commercial insurer lies in the clients to whom insurance services are provided: a captive serves its parent company, sibling companies and their specific clients.

        4 Conclusion

        In today's complex shipping market, COSCO Shipping Group's innovation in the field of finance and insurance is essential. Seeking innovation is precisely the beginning of breaking through obstacles. Where there is change, there is opportunity. COSCO Shipping Group should seize the opportunity, enter new financial fields, keep innovating and progressing, and sail toward new horizons!
(Author: Lei Hai, member of the China Maritime Arbitration Commission and its panel of arbitrator experts, and expert at the Shanghai Science and Technology Association Consulting Center)