On November 8, a reporter from 21st Century Business Herald learned that Guangdong Yuedian Property Insurance Captive Co., Ltd. ("Yuedian Captive") was recently approved to open. It is the first captive insurance company in Guangdong Province.
A so-called captive insurance company is an insurance company owned by its parent company, whose main business counterparty—the insured—is its parent company. Public information shows that Yuedian Captive was jointly funded and established by Yuedian Group and Guangdong Electric Power, with registered capital of RMB 300 million, registered in the Nansha Free Trade Zone of Guangzhou. Its business scope covers the relevant insurance business of Yuedian Group and its affiliated units, including property loss insurance, liability insurance, credit insurance and guarantee insurance, short-term health insurance and accident injury insurance.
According to a review by the 21st Century Business Herald reporter, those already in operation so far are CNPC Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd., China Railway Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd. and COSCO Shipping Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd.
Captive insurance companies have broad market prospects
Recently, the establishment of captive insurance companies has been "heating up." Not long ago, a pre-disclosure announcement by the Chinese insurance industry showed that China Datang Corporation also plans to establish China Datang Corporation Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd.
Pan Guochao, general manager of CNPC Captive, said that captive insurance companies are risk management platforms and insurance arrangement tools for large groups—the product of enterprises meeting their own risk management needs—and play an important role especially in overseas risk management under the Belt and Road Initiative. At present, CNPC Captive has undertaken a total of 28 projects in 18 countries, recovering RMB 403 million of equity for the group company's overseas insurance over four years.
Gao Dahong, general manager of China Railway Captive, gave an example: the Laos-China Railway is one of the landmark projects of the Belt and Road Initiative, with a total length of 414.516 kilometers and a total investment of about RMB 37.4 billion. Due to complex geological conditions and great construction difficulty, the demand for and requirements on insurance coverage are higher, making captive innovation the optimal solution.
Explaining the reasons, a captive industry practitioner told the 21st Century Business Herald reporter that, for example, a captive company can retain risks that its financial capacity is sufficient to bear and forecast loss premiums to reduce the overall cost of an insurance program, thereby reducing additional premium expenditures; it can also use reserves—originally retained by commercial insurers for unpaid claims and unearned premiums—for investment, which happens to take advantage of the system under which captives can set up reserves with pre-tax income.
Zheng Xiaozhe, general manager of COSCO Shipping Captive, believes that captive insurance companies understand enterprises' risk situations better and can use internal information advantages to provide personalized insurance services.
China Captive Network data show that by the end of 2016 there were 6,818 captive insurance companies worldwide, of which fewer than 150 were in the Asia-Pacific region and only 3 on the Chinese mainland. This means captive insurance companies have broad market space in China.
Using reinsurance to improve risk-bearing capacity
However, the risk prevention and control involved cannot be ignored. Previously, Zhou Yanli, former vice chairman of the CIRC, stressed on a public occasion that a captive is not equivalent to risk retention, but is a professional risk and capital management technique and institutional arrangement. Developing captives requires studying how to use time to diversify risk, how to hedge risk through product portfolios, and how to transfer risk using financial markets through the securitization of insurance risk.
Regarding the problems facing captive companies, a person from one captive company admitted frankly that captives have not been developing in China for long and enterprises lack understanding—in particular, the parent companies' shareholders still understand captives only at the level of reducing risk and securing profits. A captive should not merely control an enterprise's financial risk; it should be the overall risk management platform of the shareholder unit and strengthen cooperation with commercial insurance companies.
Some commercial insurance practitioners also point out that because some captive companies have strong bargaining power, the risk premium rates of some insurance clauses have fallen, deductibles have dropped and liability clauses have been expanded, forcing insurance companies to bear more responsibility.
Zhu Junsheng, a professor at the Institute of Finance of the Development Research Center of the State Council, suggested that establishing captive companies can help enterprises save on premiums, leverage enterprise advantages to obtain premiums from upstream and downstream industry chains, and cope with situations that commercial insurers will not underwrite and that can only be self-insured. To effectively manage and control risk, captives must improve their professionalism in risk management and rely on reinsurance to improve their capacity to bear risk events.
In addition, the captive company person mentioned above pointed out that, from an international perspective, captive companies differ from commercial insurance companies in terms of staffing, business models and regulatory environment, and expressed the hope that the regulatory model for captives can be adjusted in a targeted and moderate way in the future. It is worth noting that the "C-ROSS Phase II Construction Plan" proposes a number of regulatory rules to be improved in the second phase of C-ROSS, including solvency supervision rules for captive companies.
Source: 21st Century Business Herald 2017-11-09
