Recently, Guangdong Electric Power A issued an announcement stating that its subsidiary Yudean Captive plans to increase its capital by RMB 200 million, after which its registered capital will reach RMB 500 million. A review of Yudean Captive's 2017 annual report by Lanjing Finance shows that the company recorded a net loss of RMB 3.4248 million last year, and its insurance business income in the first two months of 2018 was only RMB 4.6183 million. In fact, Yudean Captive is not an isolated case: the four domestic captives together account for only 0.22% of the property insurance market, and compared with the international market, the number of domestic captives remains small.
Experts analyze that the high establishment threshold for captives and the relatively low level of comprehensive management at Chinese enterprises have resulted in a small number of domestic captive market participants. At the business level, domestic captives currently find it difficult to cover all business areas of their parent companies, and their risk management function has not been brought into full play. On this basis, experts suggest lowering the threshold for establishing captives so that captives can become an important platform for enterprise risk management, while enhancing the professionalism of captives in risk management.
Yudean Captive Posts RMB 3.42 Million Loss Last Year, Plans RMB 200 Million Capital Increase to Boost Underwriting Capacity
It is understood that Yudean Captive is jointly held by Yudean Group and Guangdong Electric Power, with shareholdings of 51% and 49% respectively. In this capital increase, Yudean Group and Guangdong Electric Power will contribute RMB 102 million and RMB 98 million respectively. Lanjing Finance also notes that Yudean Group and Guangdong Electric Power are related parties. According to Tonghuashun data, as of March 31 this year, Yudean Group was the largest shareholder of Guangdong Electric Power, holding 67.39% of its shares, or 3.538 billion shares. Yudean Group is jointly controlled by Guangdong Hengjian Investment and China Huaneng Group; Guangdong Hengjian Investment is wholly owned by the Guangdong Provincial SASAC, and China Huaneng Group is solely owned by the SASAC of the State Council.
The announcement shows that the capital increase is intended to further enhance Yudean Captive's capacity to underwrite insurance business and strengthen its risk resistance. Specifically, under the Insurance Law, an insurer's retained insurance amount may not exceed 10% of the sum of its paid-up capital and reserve funds. Yudean Captive is currently constrained by the size of its capital and faces cession pressure. After the capital increase, its retention limit will rise from RMB 30 million to RMB 50 million, strengthening its bargaining power in the reinsurance market, magnifying its underwriting capacity, increasing the flexibility of its own risk retention and allowing it to retain high-quality business.
So how is Yudean Captive performing at present? On May 2, Yudean Property Insurance released its 2017 annual report, showing that as of the end of last year its total assets reached RMB 322 million, with a net loss of RMB 3.4248 million for the year; as of the end of 2017, its core and comprehensive solvency ratios were both 10,524%. At the business level, Yudean Captive mainly wrote enterprise property insurance, liability insurance and hull insurance last year, with corresponding original premium income of RMB 8.9532 million, RMB 1.1299 million and RMB 12,600 respectively. According to premium data for the first two months of this year disclosed by the CBIRC, Yudean Captive achieved original insurance premium income of RMB 4.6183 million.
It is understood that Yudean Captive's business scope covers property loss insurance, liability insurance, credit and guarantee insurance, short-term health insurance and other business for Yudean Group and its affiliated units. This means that all of Yudean Captive's business comes from its shareholders, so the shareholders' business scale and related risks will affect its premium income. According to Guangdong Electric Power's annual report last year, its main business revenue reached RMB 2.069 billion, up 3.3% year on year from 2016, consisting mainly of electricity sales revenue and steam revenue.
It is worth noting that Guangdong Electric Power stated in its annual report that its development is currently constrained and urgently needs a breakthrough, and that it faces market risk, credit risk and liquidity risk. In particular, its business structure, which is dominated by coal-fired power, has weak risk resistance and insufficient momentum for the development of its core business. Guangdong Electric Power's need for risk protection provides some room for the development of Yudean Captive.
Domestic Captive Market Development Lags, with High Thresholds Limiting the Establishment of Captives
According to statistics from Captive Review, as of 2016 there were 6,618 captives worldwide, and about 70% of Global 500 companies had established captives. Setting up a captive has become one of the important ways for large international enterprises to tailor risk protection to their own needs.
Captives theoretically have unique advantages, which is why many foreign companies set up captives, Zhu Junsheng, deputy director of the Insurance Research Office of the Finance Research Institute at the Development Research Center of the State Council, told Lanjing Finance. Captives help enterprises strengthen risk management, help them obtain key management information, promote the adoption of optimal risk management methods, and align risk retention with risk appetite, thereby helping companies tighten risk control.
Chen Qibai, founder and actuary of Beijing Pengyoubao Technology Co., Ltd., told Lanjing Finance: “As various enterprises innovate, related emerging risks increase. Against this backdrop, commercial insurers are not very willing to underwrite certain risks, and captives can provide insurance to their parent companies and subsidiaries on demand.” He stressed that “as captives gradually gain underwriting experience, they will be better able to underwrite similar risks for enterprises in the same industry. In addition, underwriting similar industry enterprises can also increase the profit points of the parent company.”
Song Qinghui, an economist, positions captives as “an advanced form of enterprise risk management.”
It is worth noting that China currently has only seven captives, far from the international level. Yudean Captive was approved to open in November last year and is the seventh captive in China. The other six are COSCO Shipping Captive Insurance Co., Ltd., PetroChina Captive Property Insurance Co., Ltd., China Railway Captive Insurance Co., Ltd., CNOOC Insurance Co., Ltd., CGN Insurance Co., Ltd. and Sinopec Insurance Co., Ltd., of which CNOOC Insurance, CGN Insurance and Sinopec Insurance are registered in Hong Kong.
At the end of 2013, the former CIRC issued the Notice on Issues Concerning the Regulation of Captives, which explicitly required that an enterprise establishing a captive should be a large industrial and commercial enterprise with a prominent core business and sound profitability, and with total assets of no less than RMB 100 billion.
Against this background, Zhu Junsheng told Lanjing Finance: “For a long time China did not have captives as an organizational form, and the threshold for establishing a captive is currently relatively high. Owing to relevant regulation and the current high threshold, there are few captive market participants, and the captive market is still taking shape.”
On the other hand, “the relatively low comprehensive management capability of enterprises is also one of the reasons constraining the development of captives,” added Song Qinghui, an economist.
Captives Remain Small in Scale; Experts Say They Can Hardly Cover All Business Lines of Enterprises
How are the four domestic captives performing? According to COSCO Shipping's first-quarter solvency report, COSCO Shipping Captive, established in February last year, achieved insurance business income of RMB 338 million in the first quarter of this year, with net profit of RMB 10.9 million and net cash outflow of RMB 20.01 million. China Railway Captive achieved insurance business income of RMB 214 million in the first quarter, with net profit of RMB 61.006 million, and its net cash flow turned from an outflow of RMB 44.2213 million at the end of the previous quarter to an inflow of RMB 158 million in the first quarter. PetroChina Captive's 2017 annual report shows insurance business income of RMB 605 million last year, up 19.29% from the previous year, and it remained profitable with net profit of RMB 364 million.
Although all domestic captives are showing improving development, their scale remains relatively small. According to data currently disclosed by the CBIRC, the four domestic captives together achieved RMB 434 million in premium income in the first two months of this year, accounting for only 0.22% of the total premiums of 86 property insurers.
Apart from their late start, domestic captives also face certain limitations in their development: “Domestic captives currently mainly accumulate within the enterprise and cannot reasonably transfer operating risks, and it is also difficult for them to cover all business areas of the enterprise,” Song Qinghui analyzed.
Regarding the losses or negative net cash flow of some captives in their early years, Zhu Junsheng noted that “at the initial stage, the professionalism of operations may not have been well reflected and the risk management function of captives may not have been effectively brought into play; against this background, the value creation capability of captives needs to be further improved.”
As for the future direction of captives, Zhu Junsheng suggested: “First, the threshold for establishing captives should be lowered so that captives become an important platform for enterprise risk management; second, the professionalism of captives in risk management should be enhanced to improve their value creation capability for parent companies; third, cooperation between captives, insurers and reinsurers should be strengthened to effectively diversify risks.”
Chen Qibai also pointed out that captives should develop an in-depth understanding of the risks they face, tailor insurance for enterprises, and, as underwriting experience grows, conduct actuarial pricing, thereby optimizing enterprise risk management and fundamentally reducing enterprise risk.
On staffing, Song Qinghui added that domestic captives are mainly staffed by some miscellaneous personnel from within the enterprise, and that professionalism should be emphasized in the future, with professional matters entrusted to professionals.
As the Belt and Road Initiative advances and Chinese enterprises step up their going global pace, more and more large enterprises will face increasingly complex domestic and overseas risks. In areas where commercial insurers cannot provide risk protection, the role of captives will become more prominent, and the captive market has much to offer.
Source: Lanjing Finance 2018-05-04
